A Desperate Question

I'm wondering if anyone can help me out with this question. I think it deserves to be examined using those enlightenment values of reason and evidence. I don't really have the expertise to do it justice on my own, so I need a few more informed rational people to think about it.

Do you think the UST bond market is going to collapse soon, making it impossible for the US Gov. to service its existing debt and borrow new money to bail out elites? I think maybe. I'm keeping tabs and looking for an ungodly spike in the yield for 2-yrs and shorter. I think that's probably the point of no return.

I think it's a question worth asking. I'm not an economist, but I've been paying close attention to the economic maneuvering since about mid-summer. I think this is an issue that needs some attention, but I'm not even sure that the 2-year is the right point on the yield curve to be watching. My understanding of the bond market is limited to basic principles. I'm not sure just how foily this question is, but I asked Monkeyfister what he thought. He spent some serious time on it, barely scratched the surface, and indicated that he thinks a conversation about this is in order.

I have a few details from recent news in my head that might be important, but I think I need links before I throw them out. I'll look them up and post them if I have any takers.

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

myself, I track the futures market for

yak butter.

Never steered me wrong yet, and for someone who is still not certain what to make of "Gold Bug" advisors, a much more straightforward point of entry into market dynamics.

Yak butter - How does it taste?

I say be careful with the gold bugs. You certainly want know whether an advisor is one when considering their advice. I'm not certain what to make of them either, but I view them with suspicion.

Yeah, be careful with the Gold Bugs

You could just sort of pencil that in as a Simple Truth, along with never eat anything bigger than your head.

Seriously. If "Where do I park my T-bills?" is your idea of a Desperate Question, you've already lost my interest (heh). People are jobless and homeless by the millions and thousands more every day, little children are going hungry in the richest nation in the world, food-shortage riots are already happening, the middle class is collapsing and we are maybe months away from total economic catastrophe that could easily lead to a world-wide expansion of uncontrollable violence, the changes in global climate appear to be close to unstoppable and the resultant alterations in rainfall patterns and sea level will cost hundreds of millions of lives as well as remake the entire geopolitical structure in ways that are unpredictable but certainly unfavorable for the masses.

I'm sorry to inform you that right this moment your desperate investment quandaries do not make it onto my list of desperate concerns. Best of luck and all that.

Yak butter; delicious although an acquired taste. Best served melted in boiling water with a pinch of sea salt, in a yurt with friends on a cold winter's night. Add a nearby howling wolf pack and the specter of our future is complete. Hang onto those T-bills though. Along with a lot of other things, toilet paper will be in short supply.

i don't know jack about the markets. i do know

that the entire 'financial services' industry, which is super-global, at this point, is pulling out all the stops to make sure the house of cards doesn't collapse. and so far, it's working.

if the US 'goes down,' so do a lot of other economies. china, europe, even some of the oil kingdoms, which rely on stupid americans in SUVs driving up and down and all over the place at 'cheap' prices. none of the elite leadership of any of those concerns really want a complete crash.

they're likely to get it anyway, because most of them are too stupid to understand the reality of economic laws of nature. but they're going to make sure we get the tap dance/show for as long as they can pull it off, the better to convince people that everything is under control, that it's only a 'recession,' and that the bubble (pick your fav) "can be reinflated again with simple stimulus spending.'

the funny part is that their own greed brough about their coming demise. don't get me wrong: people with 50m or more in the bank are going to come out of all of this "ok," by the standards of people like you and me. 50m buys a lot of space in a gate community, pays salaries for guards and house slaves, and lots of netflix dvds to watch when cnn becomes the 'all riots, all the time' channel. but this nice, fluffy New World Order fiction they've been mastubating to, for so long now? well, that's the problem with not taking care of billions of poor people while feeding them teevee. eventually, they all join "al qaeda."

anyway, i agree with the above: don't ever trust a GoldBug. stupidest people on the planet, after the fundies. trust me, i've wasted a lot of time on them, and the truth is they may smoke pot and be atheists, but when it comes to their ridiculous fantasies about economic theory, they are just as lunkheaded as the gawd whisperers.

bond demand collapse and the GoldBugs

A year ago I would have been right there along with CD and BIO, but we are living now in truely new economic times. Have a look at the blue bordered charts purportedly from the Fed reproduced in this article: http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article788... It seeems to me quite reasonable that with all the deficit spending that 1). Bush did for 8 years on his wars and such, then 2). the big bailout, then 3). the Fed's sneak even bigger bailout, then 4). the stimulus package about to be enacted and 5). even more deficits that are sure to follow, it seems reasonable that the supply of treasuries to be offered (to borrow money to cover deficits) will outstrip demand. Interest rates have to go up to try to attract bond buyers when demand flags. Those interest rates ripple through the rest of the economy.

Who is going to buy all those bonds? The Chinese are starting to pull back, I understand. The dollar has stayed strong because the bailout bucks to the banks have not gone out in loans. The Fed has taken most of it back and held it as "Excess Reserves of Depository Institutions" (6th blue bordered chart). As long as it is only dribbled out, the dollar stays strong, treasury interest rates stay low and demand stays strong for the bonds. How long can that go on? I don't think you can flood the economy with all the newly printed trillions and expect to keep the lid on inflation.

What happens if too much paper money chases too few goods? It starts with "I". With the printing presses running full steam, the full faith and credit of the goverment backing the paper money gets to looking pretty raggedy. People flee to gold and other precious metals as a a safe haven when their money looses value. As a former anthropologist, I think it is stupid that people have put such a value on gold and other precious metals, but indeed they have. Go to http://seekingalpha.com/?source=headtabs and then click on "The Macro View", and go to the gold section. This will lead you to pages and pages of articles on gold, both by GoldBugs and those with diametrically opposed views. A couple of articles I was especially impressed with are: http://seekingalpha.com/article/109210-t... and http://seekingalpha.com/article/93744-pr... . I'm leaning toward the GoldBugs view right now. I've just found an institution which will hold actual precious metals as an IRA investment; I may go that route. What little I have socked away for my decrepitude, I can't afford to be eaten away by run away inflation.

I think that Stirling had the right advice

Figure out how to be happy.

"First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win." -- Mahatma Gandhi

What Donald (then Dierdre) McCloskey said.....

.. in a book I highly recommend, subtitled The Narrative of Economic Expertise, he discusses what he calls "the American Question," which is:

If you're so smart, why aren't you rich?

Which isn't meant as snark, I hasten to add; it's really a subtle question that bears on agency theory. Here, if these gold bugs are so smart, then why haven't they made themselves rich by using the information they're touting on the market itself?

Jeebus, maybe I've got to add a disclaimer to the effect that Corrente is absolutely the last place one should go to seek, or to proffer, financial advice. If I were any good at money, I'd have some. What I'm trying to do is figure out how to lead a life that matters, which isn't the name as being rich.

"First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win." -- Mahatma Gandhi

No Need to add a disclaimer for me

I am NOT asking or trying to offer financial advice.

I hate I even responded to that gold bug comment. I have no investments. I live in a very cheap apartment, work 40 or 50 hours a week, and spend another 20 hours a week or more doing what I can to keep other peoples' heads above water. see my comment below.

Also, I understand that you can't know anything about me since I've only commented here a few times over many years, and never since you started requiring a login. So, it's totally my fault that my original question came across the way it did.

Here's my point: I'm trying to make a probablistic guess about whether or not the bond market collapse is coming because I think (don't know, just think) that if I decide it's coming, it will be time to move some helpless people to a safe place.

I really appreciate the comments so far, and I'll try and put something more appropriate for this community on my blog here as soon as I have time.

:)

Phew!

I was going to update my post with the comment that a sensible rule might be "whatever lets you sleep at night" (assuming such a thing is possible...). You could make the best financial decision in the world, not sleep, and then get hit by a car crossing the street because you were so tired you didn't look both ways. I saw a quote from Harry Truman today, which now I can't find, but the effect was When I've done my best, I can't do better. I'm sure the people you are caring for know this.

That said -- and I wish CD would weigh in on this, she's smart about all this stuff -- I've ended up in "hunker down" mode, as I think that CD would say she has. Cash, hoarded food (though only a month's), gardening, not a lot of any kind of expectations more than two months out... And, very importantly, a relentless focus on community, both this one and the physical one.

"First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win." -- Mahatma Gandhi

No T-Bills to Park

It's the sovereign default or hyperinflation or both that I'm concerned with.

Guess I should have been more clear about what I was asking.

It's the social consequences, and the fact that I'm stuck in a small apartment with no way to get the money to prepare for a big fucking collapse of the system and what's going to happen to my sick wife and my nine month old grandson if the trucks stop running and the hospitals shut down and the neoconfederate survivalist fucks come pouring out of the hills. That's what makes it a desperate question.

Eesh

Listen, I'm honestly the last person to ask for financial advice or anything to do with money. I know it sounds like a copout, but asking me about money is like asking me to do your plumbing -- a complete recipe for disaster, since I know nothing about plumbing. Gardening, maybe. Just because I can tell Hank Paulson is a thief and a liar doesn't qualify me to give any sort of investment advice. It doesn't even help me balance my checkbook.

All I can say is that if you want a platform to work this out and ask others for help, we have it here. But also get to know your physical, RL neighbors. Gardening is good for that ;-) That's going to be important.

"First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win." -- Mahatma Gandhi

Eesh, indeed

That's fair enough. I don't think it's a copout at all -- just much appreciated honesty. I

Was responding to your earlier comment as you posted this.

Really think I got off on the wrong foot here. I'll try again.

Thanks

get a gun

get two.

Macro 101 and then I'm outa here:

The greatest economic danger directly in front of us is deflation, not inflation. Once deflation starts, and there are ominous early signs already, it will spiral us downwards uncontrollably and could well cause havoc as widespread and deep as the Great Depression - maybe worse. Massive government spending, which in terms of agency is not socialism or authoritarianism or reckless spendthrift Godless Liberalism but is in fact collective managed investment by ourselves in our joint future, is the singular best way to counter deflation.

In a healthy economy, massive government expenditures can result in inflation; this is not a healthy economy. The spending will (hopefully) act as a counter-balance, the inflationary pressures competing with deflationary pressures and if we're lucky - and I mean that seriously, we will need some luck because nobody is certain how to deal with this mess effectively - they will m/l balance each other out.

If inflationary signs appear it won't be for another couple of years at the earliest because the deflationary pressures are so huge. When (if?) they do, I would take it as a very good sign indeed; it will mean that the current disequilibrium in the economy has turned around and the Great Danger of runaway deflation has been avoided. There will be plenty of opportunity then to slow the inflationary pressures so we don't overshoot the recovery, simply by reducing government expenditures. Getting out of Iraq would be one good way to do that.

Inflation is the last thing we need to worry about right now, and there isn't going to be a sovereign default by the US; there is absolutely no reason to expect one. Of all the nations, the US is by far the most wealthy and resilient. The dollar is strong because of that fact; if the US were so weak, why would anyone buy Treasuries at near-zero return or hold onto dollars? If the US defaults, it will indeed be the Dark Ages and all hoarding gold will get you is a target on your back.

For hell's sakes, stop reading the GoldBugs. They're like Laffer supply-siders and their OCD fixation on tax cuts; for the GoldBugs everything is a reason to buy gold and they cherry-pick or misrepresent data to support their conjured theses. If you are really worried about ravening hordes, and who isn’t, ignore the GoldBugs and spend your time learning out how to scavenge food, trap squirrels and reload ammunition. (Survival tip #314 – The critical link with firearms isn’t lead or gunpowder – it is always the supply of formed brass. Learn to save it and reuse.)

De-leveraging is not deflation

http://seekingalpha.com/article/115677-d...
Certainly the hedge funds have (and are still?) de-leveraging. That's what took the stock market down to its current lows. Part of that was commodities which took the oil prices down. Certainly people have zipped up their pocketbooks and have reduced spending, but I don't see much deflation at the grocery store or other stores where I buy a few things. A little block of suet and seeds that I could buy to feed the birds last year for 89 cents is now $1.29. My loaf of cheap wheat bread has come down from $1.39 to $1.19, but that is still up from $.99 last year. At least, it would be nice if the lower transportation prices (from lower oil prices) and lower wheat prices found their way to the check-out counter. So where is the deflation? Except for the gas station it is business as usual.

Deleveraging is not deflation and an orange is not a banana

So what? Both are real, and both are here.

Macroeconomic concerns are about more than your personal grocery cart. See the Labor Department’s US CPI. These numbers are skewed by the decision 25 or so years ago to not include housing prices but instead something called “rental equivalent.” If housing prices were being used, it would have been easy to see that we have already been in hyper-inflation for some time and that we are now already in a serious deflation. Better, apparently, to lie to the people; tell them what they want to hear and what the government wants them to hear, because if they knew the truth they might get restless. Funny thing, eventually the truth leaks out anyway.

Concerns about deflation began to be expressed early last fall. Do some reading. Read some more.

Read what the Fed and ECB have to say.

Read Krugman, simplified or semi-wonkish or full-on wonk.

Read Brad Setser.

Read a whole lot of people. Every reputable economist thinks that deflation is either a threat worth careful consideration or is already upon us. No one worthy of good repute is worried about inflation.

Read Dani Rodrik on the complexity and uncertainty of international co-operation.

With the best of intentions the chances of getting this right are slim and none, but doing nothing or too little in the way of stimulus guarantees collapse.

Here in northern NJ, gas prices going up regularly, since early

January. I was in WI over the holidays, and gas prices there began spiking (up 10 cents overnight) shortly after Christmas, iirc. On the trip back, were mostly 20 cents or so higher.

When I got back to NJ, gas was till below $1.50/gal ($1.43 in my town), but by the time I needed to fill up it was going up and hasn't stopped.

But, food? Little change from higher prices, altho' perhaps a few more sales on dairy products, meats.

I haven't figured out why prices changed. In honor of the new administration?

You May Find Yourself Living In a Shotgun Shack...

If a complete collapse comes - and I think that's unlikely because the Chinese and Russians and everyone else has no place else to go but US T-bills, we're fucked, but not as fucked as the euros so they Chinese and other folks can complain, but they have no place else to go* - but if for some reason the entire thing comes apart, then you have to ask yourself where do you want to be. Personally, sitting with an assault rifle on a stack of gold bars trying to keep the hordes away sounds like an awful existence.

My people have been poor through war (the Civil War) and depression (the Great One), but we've never gone hungry. The reason is simple, we have a small patch of land. It's worth little, but it's got fresh water and you can grow food on it (and tobacco).

For folks who find themselves with a little money, I'd suggest you might be happier purchasing a couple of acres within a day's drive of your house. In some rural parts of the country, you can get land for $1,000 - $2,000 an acre. It doesn't matter if it's out in the middle of nowhere. In fact, it's better that way. Ground water so you could drill a well would be a plus. If you want a building, you can build yourself a cabin from a kit for about $10,000.

And here's the thing, it not only serves as a great backstop in times of trouble, but can also be a good thing in good times. You can take the kids there to camp out. You can see the stars once you're away from civilization. You can shoot guns or bows and arrows at targets or just run free in the great outdoors. You can grow things there in good times and in bad.

For less than $20,000 you have a safe haven and a vacation property!

Or, you know, you can buy a bunch of gold bars and an AK and wait to be robbed.

* Don't get me wrong, it's going to be bad, but I think more like Great Depression bad, than apocalyptic bad. And, yes, the Government seems to be doing all the wrong things and making it worse, but the Government did that under Hoover, too.

"Do what you feel in your heart to be right -- for you'll be criticized anyway. You'll be damned if you do, and damned if you don't. " - Eleanor Roosevelt

"not as fucked as the euros"

That phrasing kind of takes the joy out of "We're Number One!" doesn't it?

Thanks for all the links BIO

I have some reading to do, and I think that makes a hole lot more sense than advice like "For hell's sakes, stop reading the GoldBugs". Even when people are bat-shit goofy you learn by reading and listening. I was forced to take ROTC back in the Stone Age when I went to college. It was amazing and enlightening to hear how my instructor saw the world (kind of like the general in Dr. Strangelove). Thanks again for the links.

Many Thanks

I appreciate all the comments. I found them very helpful as I looked into this further. You good folks helped me gain some clarity and offer some comments to others that they found useful. I feel a bit better about things now. I’ll offer a few opinions with the disclaimer that under no circumstances should you use anything I say as the basis for a financial decision. I am so behind the curve on this subject that I found the Macro 101 and the links helpful, and I am grateful that Bringiton took the time to post them.

1. The bond market. I committed a rather painful analytical error formulating the original question, and a n00b error at that. I was looking at some things that might be evidence that a bond-market crash is on the way. I conflated the possibility of a crash, which might occur as a result of a bubble bursting, with a collapse, which is a different matter entirely. These two concepts need to be kept separate in any economic discussion. To compound my error, I posted in haste on the basis of some second-hand information that I was never able to verify from a reliable source. Buyer beware, etc.

2. China – I think the argument that China has more to lose than to gain from a collapse of our bond market is a fair assessment. Most of their reserves seem to be in dollars and dollar-denominated assets, there’s no alternative to the dollar as reserve currency for now, and it would be better for everyone if we recover and resume purchasing imports from the rest of the world – even if our imports never regain the levels we’ve seen them over the last few years. Given the overall geostrategic situation for all the big actors, I think it’s reasonable in the short term to expect not only China, but also the U.K. and Japan, to support the treasury market by taking losses that wouldn’t make sense on purely economic grounds as long as they have the cash to do so, and absent a game-changing event. This is as much a political consideration for these countries as an economic one, and it’s the reason I’m comfortable discounting a bond market collapse at this time. However, I think it is foolish to count on being the one indispensible country for much longer. Obviously, we need to stop fucking around and get our house in order.

3. Deflation/Hyperinflation. After reading into this argument, I’m in the deflationist camp. I think the comment about standing inside the burning building and worrying about the cold outside has a lot of merit. The question will be resolved eventually not by arguments, but by events, and I don’t know enough about currency flows at the macro level to be comfortable offering further speculation.

4. On the other comments, which I enjoyed reading very much – Getting to know one’s neighbors and acquiring an acre or two of dirt are very good ideas. I would caution anyone purchasing land to look carefully and be sure you’re getting what you want before you buy, especially if you’re planning on using it for horticulture. Soil quality and groundwater will make or break you. I wholeheartedly endorse getting to know one’s neighbors. I am also in hunker-down mode, and have been for over a year now. I do have guns, but when it comes to politics, I advocate purely non-violent methods so long as you’re dealing with a functioning state. That’s not something I’m prepared to compromise on, and I think we need to get a lot better at non-violent resistance to authority in the U.S. My concern about the neconfederate survivalists is a serious one. Their numbers are growing. I live in the Deep South with no hope of getting out anytime soon. Last year I published a letter to the editor and encouraged people to protest on behalf of an activist who was arrested by the police. I made a simple, classic argument against police state powers on constitutional grounds. Two days after the letter was published, some of these people looked me up in the phone book and tried to recruit me. Armed white supremacy is real, at least in this part of the country. I am very angry at both the national government and my state for not doing more to contain it over the last few years.

I plan to do some occasional posting as soon as I can figure out what I would like to say here. I’m working on a series of posts that I may offer here in a couple of weeks if they turn out as well as I hope they do. I’ll try and make a habit of stopping in to comment from time to time. I’ll continue to do the bulk of my blogging elsewhere for now, for several reasons, not least of which is that it takes an assload of work to produce something that I feel is of sufficient quality to publish under the Corrente banner. Thanks to everyone here for setting such high standard for all these years.

I would like VERY much to read more posts

and thanks for the kind words.

As for the "high standards" -- heck, don't let that stop you! I've written plenty of bad posts over the years, and I can give you a list of people who will tell you about them!

Now, if you just want to write, instead of waiting to post the perfect post, I'd be very interested in your life experience stuff -- particularly concrete detail on hunker down, what you do, what that feels like, et cetera. And also what to do with the survivalist types. We've got plenty of 'em out in the woods up here in Zone 5b, so I'd be interested to hear how you deal with them.

"First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win." -- Mahatma Gandhi

Encouragement builds confidence

I'm in an urban area in a small apartment right now, working in the public sector. About 90 miles from the Katrina impact zone. I took a shot at laying the foundation to get off the grid back in 2003. I made some bad choices in location. I saw some bureaucratic warfare coming my way and fled into a graduate political science program. Good move! The dept. i was working for got liquidated about six months after I left. I got to study world organization with an old school internationalist who work on the Law of the Sea convention and had 30 years worth of human trafficking files to work with. Got to write a thesis under him. That got me some much needed intellectual maturity. But I had to take out student loans and move into the city. Ended up carrying rent and property loans, so I've been overextended for a couple of years.

Real estate was overvalued when I bought the property. I should have held onto the money and waited the bubble out, but at the time I thought the situation was more urgent that it was. Sold about a year ago for a modest loss, and will retire that loan next month.

So, right now, hunkering down means hoarding food, keeping as many medical supplies and baby supplies for the grandkid and things like that as we can, and having everything in order so we can flee to my parents' house out in the country if we need to. The goal is to be able to weather a short-term disruption and keep our ears to the ground so we know when it's time to get out. We don't really have any space for containers outside, but we're going to start experimenting with some indoor gardening as soon as we free up the cash from the property loan. My wife has a green thumb.

The white supremacists here tend to congregate in small enclaves, but they leave signs if you know what you're looking for. I'll deal with them in more detail a little later. There are "white hat" survivalists too -- they don't call themselves that. That's just what I call them. Not political, live-and-let-live, well-prepared types. I'll try and share what I know with you about the way these people live and operate when I have some free time.

If you see...

... a "Post to my blog" link, feel free to use it. Let's not bury things in comments...

"First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win." -- Mahatma Gandhi

Found it!

O.k. if I share things I'm trying to do on other sites?

Yes, danps does

But if you're cross posting, please let the readers know by saying something up top like "originally posted at Corrente", and if you want to be really nice, something like "cross-posted to Corrente" elsewhere. In general, that's a good way to differentiate yourself from the people who just copy and paste whatever wherever. Now, have at it!

"First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win." -- Mahatma Gandhi

behind the curve

Welcome to the club. Under current circumstances, everyone on the planet is behind the curve. There has never been an economic crisis quite like this one, and the path to disaster is so interlocked that any move to make some part better in one direction also makes something worse in another. Anyone offering simple solutions, like micro "Buy Gold" or macro "Cut Taxes" should be viewed with massive distrust.

Glad you found the links useful. Sorry if I seemed abrupt, but hey that's me so you'll have to get used to it. I'd certainly like to hear more about what you're up to and what you think. I have friends in NO but they're on the upscale, established (seven generations) side of things so when they say they're doing OK it likely doesn't reflect reality for most people.

As to quality, for heaven's sakes don't worry. Your writing is fine and besides, they let me hang around so the bar can't be all that high.

Thanks!

It wasn't the abruptness, per se. It was that I'd anticipated all sorts of negative responses, and prepared to deal with them in a mature and productive way. But I didn't expect anyone to insinuate that I was a greedhead looking to figure our where to park my money. That's how I took one of your comments. Later I realized it had a lot to do with the way I phrased the question. NBD.