All we really need to do is fix Medicare, and then make enrollment automatic for everyone. But then that would break the bond of trust that President Obama and the members of Congress have established with Karen Ignagni. That seems to be a much stronger bond than they have with the other 306 million of us.
Normally Dr McCanne is a sober and sensible blogger and policy analyst for PNHP, but sometimes he unleashes a real zinger, like this one in a discussion on what happens to the younger spouse when an older spouse becomes eligible for Medicare.
If you get your insurance through your spouse's employer, what happens to you when s/he retires? If both of you are 65, no problem. If you're close in age, and the older spouse is active, healthy, and enjoying working, s/he can put off retiring until both of you are 65 and eligible for Medicare.
But real life is full of messy little details like May-December relationships, or older, more expensive workers being forced out by their Ebenezer Scrooge bosses whether they want to retire or not. What then?
The sensible solution, of course, is to make everyone eligible for Medicare from age 0, but noooooooo, we can't have that. What would we do with all our unemployed health policy wonks if things were simple?
- hipparchia's blog
- Login or register to post comments



Front page
Comments
Here in this state,
Ted Kennedy had a saying which he used quite often: Medicare for all, cradle to grave. He's been asked recently what happened with that famous line, without much response from his people.
Andre, have any links for Ted Kennedy on Medicare for All?
Thnx. It's been a long time since he's said that or my search term wasn't very good.
No I don't
but that was a line he used on many of his campaign speeches, and having gone thru all of them with him (I voted in all but one of them), I've heard it on many occasions.
Ted Kennedy on Medicare for all (2005)
A Democratic Blueprint for America's Future: [edited to get the whole Medicare quote in]
It's not single-payer, but it seems clear that he meant that Medicare should be available to every person in the US.
There's also this:
I really wonder what's going to happen in the fall-winter semester if (as seems likely) we have epidemic flu. I have no idea if my college is making any plans other than making flu shots available.
---------------
We can't afford not to have single-payer!
Thanks, LN,
hearing those words gave us some hope that everybody would be covered, many words that have given us hope since Bobby. If I were a cynic, I would say that they were only operable until we controlled all three branches. I do remember having a bit of a discussion with the editor of the Boston Globe because of the coverage they did not give his proposed bill, and their response was that the Senator was satisfied with their coverage. Hmmm. I don't belittle what Ted is going thru right now, my brother died of the same thing, but if those who are striving to protect his legacy don't understand that this hope best be fulfilled, there will be many of us in his home state who will have footnotes to his legacy.
Thnx, to ALNM and Andre -- for the speech and the reminder that
Ted Kennedy once upon a time wanted essentially single payer.
I conjecture that since he was such a strong and early supporter of Obama he's not going to go against Obama on what BO thinks the health insurance reform should be.
Since, if he wanted real health CARE reform, he simply could not go along with BO.
Sad. Very, very sad. Sen. Kennedy could have had a legacy of real health CARE for everyone, and his name would have gone down in history as the author of that plan. Alas.
Simple. He got sick with a catastrophic illness,
which means his doctors and nurses and technicians, all of whom he can respect and like, are sharing what pressure *they're* getting to kill single payer.
They can use any untrue and meretricious argument they can come up with, to say that single payer will kill patients -- and since they have his life in his hands, who is he to argue?
Except...
... we also know that there are many, many doctors and nurses who support single payer, some of whom have live-blogged here. And I think there are many, many more who wouldn't use a patient's illness to browbeat them politically. Sheesh.
"First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win." -- Mahatma Gandhi
Except once he got sick, he shut up.
at precisely the time you'd expect for him to cement his legacy.
No links -- but it's my hunch that he wouldn't stop fighting on the issue he said he wanted as his defining contribution unless someone told him to stop, and in that I'm being charitable. I don't want to think that he said, "healthcare for me, and none for thee", when push comes to shove, and he faced an illness requiring all the healthcare he could buy.
If he's fighting to live, then he's in the perfect place to say, "I've got access to some of the best healthcare in the world, as a Senator. Why don't the American people deserve the same?" If he's accepted death as coming soon, why not fight for universal healthcare as his dying declaration? And, if he's in between, as most cancer fighters are, why not use the pulpit he's carved out over at least 30 years to be a model for the system at its best? Yes, that's asking a Kennedy to use his private pain, one more time, for the public good, but he hasn't shirked that special duty before, and I'd doubt he'd shirk it now except under duress.
cg eye, you need to furnish links with that
just to keep me from believing it's BS on its face. mmkay?
That's sheer unsupported speculation on your part, right there.
We have no way of knowing what the docs, nurses, or techs are saying to Senator Kennedy.
We can admit that we’re killers … but we’re not going to kill today. That’s all it takes! ~ Captain James T. Kirk, Stardate 3193.0
1 John 4:18
No, it's my opinion.
My opinion about Kennedy won't be the opinion of the majority of the American population, but I can live with that.
ted kennedy, on national health insurance, 1974
here.
i haven't had the chance to listen to all of it yet.
Oh, as for the 'killing patients' meme
that's already spread on Firedoglake:
http://seminal.firedoglake.com/diary/6145
Without Health Care, My Patients Will Die: Please Don’t Sacrifice Them For Single Payer
Is this is what Congress is getting from the 'left', what are they getting from the pundits they respect? And if you don't think Kennedy isn't getting this opinion by the bushel, then he must be trying to heal in splendid isolation.