July 28, 2009

Paul Krugman explains single payer. Under the headline -- get this:

Irresponsible punditry

I'm with Cohen on this one. That's a FAIL.

In fact, two FAILs. One for the late date; the second for the complete lack of awareness that the date is late.

NOTE Here's Krugman's single payer blogging oeuvre. How'd that "single payer's not politically possible" trout get in the milk, anyhow?

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I ripped him for this.

In an email.

I admit, it wasn't nice.

But I'm taking the gloves off.

Hell, I'm never going to be invited to the White House for dinner anyway.

Medicare for All is Civil Rights

mass

I'd love to see your email and I'm sure others here would as well.

The lot of them, Krugman included, have kept up the drumbeat that single-payer is politically impossible. Apparently Krugman, in part, formulated his theory from the testimony of an ignorant blowhard. Much of that comes from elites simply repeating the claim and in other cases rigged polls courtesy of Celinda Lake and others.

When the public, free of coaching, overwhelmingly favors single-payer then it's anything but impossible.

Of course conviction and leadership from the White House would have helped immeasurably but the lack of conviction was evident from the start and the "leadership" is a joke and confirmation of the lack of conviction.

One Person's Waste is Another's Income

and even NYC academic facility docs are moonlighting these days.

Of course, there has always been a profit motive in medicine. Doctors who own their own imaging machines order more imaging tests; to take an example from my moonlighting work, a doctor who owns a scanner is seven times as likely as other doctors to refer a patient for a scan. In regions where there are more doctors, there is more per capita use of doctors’ services and testing. Supply often dictates demand.

But financial considerations have never been as prominent as they are today, probably because so many hospitals and doctors, especially in large metropolitan areas, are in financial trouble. More and more doctors are trying to sell their practices, or are negotiating with hospitals for jobs, equipment or financial aid.

At hospitals, uncompensated care is increasing as patients suffering from the economic downturn lose health insurance. Admissions and elective procedures — big moneymakers — are declining. Hospitals are cutting administrative costs, staff and services.

“More and more you’ll see people in medicine get M.B.A.’s,” a doctor told me at a seminar, in a prediction borne out in my experience. “We are in a total crisis, and I don’t know the answer.”

My alma mater's medical school started a program several years ago that was unique in the nation at the time -- a combination MD/MBA program.

I don't begrudge the docs a good living; every laborer is worthy of his hire, after all. But note what this one says about uncompensated care. That's a bigger slice of every hospital's budget than it was five years ago -- and places like John Peter Smith and Parkland are being sucked into closing down because of it.

Single payer would stop that.


We can admit that we’re killers … but we’re not going to kill today. That’s all it takes! ~ Captain James T. Kirk, Stardate 3193.0

1 John 4:18

Cohen wrote a good piece, except

(referring to Obama's recent rhetoric on health insurance):

When Democratic leaders start borrowing right wing rhetoric, we know our activism has not been strong or progressive enough.

start borrowing???

I guess paying attention is hard.

Policy not party!

I had to do a double check on the date of Jeff Cohen's piece-yup

TODAY. With all the good advice that could have been effective, oh, last January-February, probably into March-April.

Now.

To be fair (no pun intended), did Cohen write this kind of thing earlier? When we unterbussen were begging for established voices to join ours???

Setting the record straight is a good thing

But yes, I agree.

"First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win." -- Mahatma Gandhi

Help Corrente ...

... keep the heat on!

Subscribe to make a monthly payment and keep the hamsters who keep the mighty servers turning in kibble.

No PayPal Account required! Thank you!

Recent comments

I support Americans United for Separation of Church and State.