"Like Pouring Water into a Dry Sponge"

Via Economist's View, who also used the same riff in their headline, because it's too damn good not to use, Robert Reich on the Bush + Reid + Pelosi + Obama + Paulson trillion dollar bailout:

The Dow is see-sawing but the reality is that the Bailout of All Bailouts isn't working. Credit markets are largely still frozen. Despite all the money going directly to the big banks, despite all the government guarantees and loans and special tax breaks, despite the shot-gun weddings and bank mergers, despite the willingness of the Treasury and the Fed to do almost whatever the banks have asked, the reality is that credit is not flowing. It's not flowing to distressed homeowners. It's not flowing to small businesses. It's not flowing to would-be homeowners with good credit ratings. Students are having a harder time borrowing for their tuition. Auto loans are drying up.

Why? Because the underlying problem isn't a liquidity problem. As I've noted elsewhere, the problem is that lenders and investors don't trust they'll get their money back because no one trusts that the numbers that purport to value securities are anything but wishful thinking. The trouble, in a nutshell, is that the financial entrepreneurship of [fraud, looting, theft; no value was created, so it's not entrepreneurship] recent years -- the derivatives, credit default swaps, collateralized debt instruments, and so on -- has undermined all notion of true value.

But pouring money into these banks, expecting they'll turn around and lend to small businesses and Main Streets, is like pouring water into a dry sponge. Nothing will come out of it because Wall Street is so deep in debt that the banks are using the extra money to improve their balance sheets. They're hoarding it because their true balance sheets -- considering the off-balance sheet vehicles they created over the past several years -- are in such rotten shape.

In other words, taxpayers are financing a massive effort to save Wall Street's balance sheets from Wall Street's previous off-balance-sheet excesses. It won't work. It can't work. The entire effort is merely saving the asses of lots of executives and traders who got us into this mess in the first place, and whose asses should not be saved at taxpayer risk and expense.

What to do? Immediately require the Treasury to stop the broad Wall Street recapitalization, and require Wall Street to lend the money directly to Main Street. At the same time, force Wall Street to write down its true balance sheets: Let the executives and traders take the hit. Let their shareholders and even their creditors take the hit for Wall Street's collosal irresponsibility. This is the only true way to restore trust. It's also the only way to save Main Street's small businesses, homeowners, students, and everyone else.

Yeah, like that's gonna happen.

What needs to happen is that we need to have one last orgy of looting and theft before the bad cops leave office.

Then, when the good cops take office, they'll arrange for the little people to pay for it all! This is called "fiscal responsibility."

Priorities, Bob! Priorities!

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

In Reich's first post about the meltdown,

he writes:

Leadership isn't just about passing a big piece of legislation. It's about explaining and thereby gaining trust and confidence from a public -- including a global public -- that's otherwise afraid and confused. A credible and powerful explanation is necessary right now -- about where we've been, how we got into this mess, and how a particular plan (in this case, the bailout), will get us out of it. Yet Paulson has proven himself uniquely unable to explain anything to anyone.

Paulson CAN'T explain it without seriously implicating himself AND his buddies. He helped cause the debacle. Why these criminals are now allowed to be involved in crisis-solving is beyond me.

Congress has really screwed the pooch on this one. And the total lack of care and concern for America and its future well-being is just outrageous.

Damn them to hell.

Short people

always causing trouble.
BTW, The Shrill One gave an interview to Terry Gross on Fresh Air yesterday. Sounds like Paulson and the Congress screwed up, Bernanke is running out of options and Krugman is terrified that containment failed when we didn't rescue Lehmann Brothers.
I don't like the word terrified when it comes from the mouth of a Nobel Prize winning economist. It makes me terrified.
Come together at The Confluence

Come together at The Confluence