Murdoch's WSJ sets the "public option" as the outer-fringe of the health care debate

A Journal editorial declares the reputed health care "public option" to be"The End of Private Health Insurance."

The UHC optimist reads this as "ObamaCare will destroy of the death-by-spreadsheet industry."

The shrill may see this as cementing the idea that the "public option" is radical surgery, rather than triangulation from the guys who told zombie banks: "eat our brains, please!"

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

murdoch, my left foot

it's purported liberals, like ezra klein and uwe reinhardt, who are setting up the public option as outer fringe.

Er, no

They're not liberals. They're "progressives."

"First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win." -- Mahatma Gandhi

purported

adjective
reputed or claimed; alleged: We saw no evidence of his purported wealth.

That's the glory of post-partisanship

Neo-cons and neo-liberals beat as one, singing Kumbaya at our funeral.

kumbaya

coming together over a song where no one seems to agree on the date of origin, authorship, or lyrics.

uwe reinhardt, liberal or not,

has a bit of a conflict of interest.

Dear me! And a Times-man, too!

Here:

Perhaps his conflict of interest influenced his thinking. Reinhardt serves on the board of Amerigroup Inc., a managed care insurer that makes its profit by serving mostly public sector clients (Medicare, Medicaid, Medicare Advantage). He owns 137,558 shares of Amerigroup stock and earned $226,531 for board service last year, according to the latest Securities and Exchange Commission filings (information not in the Economix blog item nor in his short biography that appears on the Times website).

"First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win." -- Mahatma Gandhi

yep

and also from merrill goozner, a couple of years ago:

...liberal economist Uwe Reinhardt, a very insightful and caring man who also happens to sit on the boards of a hospital chain, an insurance company, and a medical device maker.

Times public editor should know about that

He's from Knight Ridder, so not all bad...

"First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win." -- Mahatma Gandhi

Ceci Connolly gets lick in against DFH/leftie UHC/public plan

supporters in news (analysis? article in the WaPo today. Kind of scary that those who want actual "affordable, high-quality care available to every American" are making it difficult for Obama to deliver "affordable, high-quality care available to every American."

The title may not be Connolly's responsibility, but it sure is the WaPo's: Health-Care Dialogue Alarms Obama's Allies. Which allies would those be, pray tell? Big Pharma? Big Insurance? Do tell!

As Congress returns to begin an intense debate over reshaping the nation's $2.2 trillion health-care system, prominent left-leaning organizations and liberal House members are issuing a warning to their Democratic allies: Don't cave on us.

The early skirmishing -- essentially amounting to friendly fire -- is perhaps the clearest indication yet of the uphill battle President Obama faces in delivering on his promise to make affordable, high-quality care available to every American.

SNIP

More than 70 House Democrats recently warned party leaders that they will not support a broad health reform bill that does not offer consumers a government-sponsored policy, and two unions withdrew from a high-profile health coalition because it would not endorse a public plan.

So, what's to worry about? Oh, yeah...

Last week, two top administration officials suggested that Obama is open to compromise on the public plan, comments that set off alarm bells in some corners of his party.

"That's what got the left nervous. I took that as a signal to Senator Grassley" that Obama is willing to negotiate around an issue Grassley has vehemently opposed, said Len Nichols, health policy director at the New America Foundation, a nonprofit think tank, referring to Sen. Charles E. Grassley (R-Iowa). "It was the first time the president indicated he could live without it."

Maybe, but he's sure hinted he could live without it.

During last year's campaign, Obama proposed offering a government-sponsored plan as a low-cost alternative for Americans who are having trouble purchasing insurance in the private market. Proponents say it would reduce costs because it would not need to make a profit or pay large executive salaries.

SNIP

"The sacred cow on the left and the right is the public plan," said former senator Thomas A. Daschle, who was Obama's first choice to oversee the reform effort.

In comments last week, Nancy-Ann DeParle, head of the White House Office of Health Reform, said the ultimate solution may rest in how a public plan is defined.

"There are different breeds of public plans that could be part of this," she said, explaining that the Medicare model is not the only approach.

Feel comforted?

Yesterday, a spokeswoman clarified that Obama has not taken the idea off the table but is willing to consider any proposal that meets his broad goals. "The administration is open to all ideas for achieving those goals," Linda Douglass said.
(My emphasis)

Tom Daschle's respectable again?

That didn't take long!

"First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win." -- Mahatma Gandhi