The invaluable McClatchy:
In stark legal turnaround, Obama now resembles Bush
President Barack Obama is morphing into George W. Bush, as administration attorneys repeatedly adopt the executive-authority and national-security rationales that their Republican predecessors preferred.In courtroom battles and freedom-of-information fights from Washington, D.C., to California, Obama's legal arguments repeatedly mirror Bush's: White House turf is to be protected, secrets must be retained and dire warnings are wielded as weapons.
"It's putting up a veritable wall around the White House, and it's so at odds with Obama's campaign commitment to more open government," said Anne Weismann, chief counsel for Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, a legal watchdog group.
I suppose Obama's vote to gut the Fourth Amendment with FISA [cough] Reform could have been a tip-off... But even I -- racist dead-ender though I am -- didn't expect Obama to "morph" into Bush! McClatchy goes on to give the bill of particulars:
The Bush White House sought to keep e-mails secret. The Obama White House has followed suit. The Bush White House sought to keep visitor logs secret. The Obama White House, so far, takes the same view.
Petaluma, Calif., resident Carolyn Jewel and the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a legal activist group, sued the Bush administration over warrantless wiretaps. The Bush administration said that the lawsuit endangered national security. The Obama administration now agrees. ...
Similarly, the Bush administration objected to an American Civil Liberties Union request for access to documents that include photographs that reportedly show the abuse of foreign prisoners held by the U.S. military in Iraq and Afghanistan. The Obama administration declared in April that it would release the photographs.
Three weeks later, Obama reversed course...
On the opposite coast, a similar drama is playing out in a clash over so-called "torture flights."
An ACLU lawsuit, initially filed in U.S. District Court in San Jose, Calif., contends that the Boeing subsidiary Jeppesen DataPlan knowingly supported a CIA operation that flew terrorism suspects to brutal overseas prisons. The Bush administration invoked the "state secrets" privilege in an effort to stop the suit. ... The Obama administration now says the same, after a three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled April 21 that the case could proceed.
For both arguments, the two administrations relied on the attestations of the same man: former Bush CIA Director Michael Hayden.
More bipartisanshit....
- lambert's blog
- Login or register to post comments
- 1+[encrypted]+#b94+
Printer-friendly version


Front page


Comments
When I Saw
this on the McClatchy website this morning I was shocked at the headline, to say nothing of the pull-no-punches language of the article. I have them bookmarked precisely because of their accuracy (formerly as Knight Ridder) during the Iraq run up.
IMO their reporting on Obama has been accurate and attentive to broken campaign pledges but not overly critical in their almost daily lead articles on the new President. So just my 2 cents but this article seems a bit more aggressive and I can only hope it continues.
Rahm Emanual
I've got two words for you: Rahm Emanual. Really, I'd put money that he's a very central part of the continuation of this policy. Obama didn't pick Rahm by mistake.
But, we've always been at war with Eastasia...