On the torture tapes, please talk to the techs

lambert's picture

At the very end of Froomkin's chat yesterday, there is this little gem:

Stony Brook, N.Y.: Everybody seems to accept the claim that the CIA tapes were destroyed. Given the long history of deceptions by this administration, shouldn't we ask for proof, or at least sworn statements to that effect?

Dan Froomkin: A good point. And consider this. Michael Isikoff and Mark Hosenball write in Newsweek: "At one point portions of the tapes were electronically transmitted to CIA headquarters in Langley, Va., so a small number of officials there could review them. A counterterrorism source, who also asked for anonymity when discussing this subject, said that there was no reason to believe that any recordings of such an electronic feed still exist."

No, no, of course not. No reason whatever. (Except that, as we know from the Stasi and, say, Guatemala, totalitarian regimes hang onto all their data.)

And who knows the dataflows? Where the data goes, its nature and volume, its timing, and who has privileges to see it? The techs. Could we talk to them, please? Didn't we get good results when we talked to Alexander Butterfield?

There are two examples I can think of where the techs--curiously, or not--were never talked to.

First, Abu Ghraib, where whistleblower Samuel Provance, though the administrator of the top secret Abu Ghraib network, was never asked what data moved across the network, and where it went, and who had the privileges to access it.

Second, gwb43.com, where, despite literally millions of White House emails being conveniently "lost," the companies that handled the offsite backup were never talked to, let alone subpoenaed.

And my own personal data point:

I do have a tech contracting world, and from that world I heard that indeed all torture was captured and yes, it went to the West Wing. (As of course it would, starting with the fact that they’re all 24 fans in the West Wing, and ending with the fact that torture corrupts everything it touches, and they like that, partly because they’re evil, and partly because making people complicit in their evil helps their policy objectives.)

So, please, can we try to work the old talk-to-the-small-fish to get to the big fish tactic by talking to the techs? Thank you. If you want the next Alexander Butterfield, that's where to look. Because you know all the Christianists on the administrative side are going to lie like rugs for Dear Leader, so what other kind of small fish is there?

Alternatively, we could write yet another Sternly Worded Letter ....

NOTE Reworked from a comment here.

If you liked this post, buy the author some books.

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

war crimes

awesome. i was thinking why, after all that has happened, should we believe "them" about anything.

and of course, if it hadn't been explained to us peasants that the tapes were destroyed, why -- someone might insist on their being used -- in court, in the hague.

Help the hamsters with their winter heating bill ...

… as they power the wheels that turn the servers at The Mighty Corrente Building. Please, won’t you help them keep their cages shiny?

No PayPal Account required! Give the hamsters immediate relief!

Or Subscribe to make a monthly payment!

Corrente is completely supported by contributions from readers. Thank you!

Download Citibank Plutonomy files

Part 1 [PDF]

Part 2 [PDF]

Good reading! Favorite quote: What could go wrong?
Beyond war, inflation, the end of the technology/productivity wave, and financial collapse, we think the most potent and short-term threat would be societies demanding a more ‘equitable’ share of wealth.

The 12 Word Platform

1. Medicare for All

2. End the Wars

3. Tax the Rich

4. A Jobs Guarantee

Senior fellows of The Mighty Corrente Building

Leah (CA), Lambert (PA/ME), RDF (??), BDBlue (DC), Hipparchia (FL), MsExPat (NY), letsgetitdone (DC), twig (LA), Tony Wikrent, (NC), jawbone (PA).

Corresponding fellows

danps.

Western Coordinator

coyotecreek

Correspondents

Health care reform: DCBlogger.

Fellows emeritus

mjs, Riggsveda, Tresy, Tom, hekebolos, chicagodyke, shystee, and Xenophon, Vastleft (MA), Sarah (TX).

Random term

The Beltway; for background, see here. Denotes the Village, but with connotations of ruling (as opposed to governing), absolutism, wretched excess, decay, and ultimate collapse.

I support Americans United for Separation of Church and State.

Americans United is dedicated to preserving the constitutional principle of church-state separation as the only way to ensure religious freedom for all Americans.