Sam the Sham: Esquire unsuspectingly skewers fake video

Last week, I posted a video of "Sam," whose first dating video was chosen by Esquire as the worst on the Internet. "Sam" had been nice enough to give Correntewire a shoutout in one of his recent follow-up videos.

We're in the inconvenient-truth biz around here, so I must 'fess up to a convenient sin of omission.

You heard it here first, folks: Sam's a fake.

Well, he didn't start out as a fake. Remember the Thermians in Galaxy Quest, and how they thought the small-screen actors were real? It's kind of like that.

Except this time, instead of an adorable alien, the guileless one was Esquire.com writer Daniel Murphy, who unwittingly pilloried a fictitious character he found on a movie-promo MySpace page.

I'd feel a little empathy for the self-buffaloed writer, but I'm not sure empathy is his thing. Per Murphy, the kind of woman Sam might meet is "probably fat." And another of his failed-flirt five is, he says, "doing a rather serviceable impression of a man with a traumatic head injury."

So how did this misunderstanding-turned-hoax come about? How did a promo clip for a little-known movie become an internet phenomenon viewed over 75,000 times?

Here's how it happened:

  • In 2003, New York-based director Andrew Y. Park cast actor Dennis Hurley (now best known for his popular short film, The Albino Code) as "Sam," in a 16mm short called Perfect Profile
  • About a year ago, to give the film a little more exposure, they made a MySpace page for Sam, which included a link to the movie. Anyone who looked at the page in detail, like say someone who was writing about it for a major national media outlet, would have seen that it was a promo for a video.
  • Once the article was published, and traffic started pouring in, Park decided to remove Perfect Profile from the MySpace page and enjoy the unexpected ride, fueled by the story being picked up by Fark and Digg
  • Dennis was invited to appear on "The Frank Show," a Tuscon-based radio program (audio file here), which extended "Sam's" shelf-life a little
  • Dennis is an old friend and colleague of mine, and he and Andrew were nice enough to let us shoot a Corrente-themed episode — which I want to make sure isn't construed as an endorsement on their part of our "boldy shrill" politics — before we helped get the word out about the story behind the story
  • With the buzz from the original accidental "hoax" dying down, Andrew decided to release a final meta-video, about Sam going on a date that resulted from his newfound "fame"
  • And now Park has come forth with his story about the experience, including a little online anthropology, as he categorizes the various types of feedback that "Sam" received.

Dennis shares his own recollections here:

I found acting as Sam in Andrew Park's short thriller Perfect Profile to be very rewarding, as it was a leading role and a "meaty" leading role, at that. I never imagined the exposure I would get some 5 years after shooting the film in New York City.

We wrapped shooting in 2003. When the film was finally finished in 2006, Andrew and I met for lunch and discussed marketing possibilities for the film. Andrew came up with the idea of giving "Sam" a MySpace page with a dating video. We filmed the dating video, and put it on the page. We gained a handful of unsuspecting MySpace friends, but after a month the friend requests stopped coming and we figured it was time to reveal our "secret." We posted the whole film on the MySpace page, under the dating video. No comments came back, so we just let it be.

Fast forward to January, 2008. Esquire comes out with a list of what they call the 5 worst dating videos online. The article's author, Dan something or other, posted "Sam's" first. Keep in mind that Dan must have found this video, unaware of the actual film on the MySpace page. I was quite surprised that a huge magazine like Esquire was able to let this shoddy research take place and let this fake story slip through the cracks.

The MySpace friend list doubled, as bloggers and MySpacers requested to be Sam's friend and offered him either scathing comments or sympathetic support for his girl troubles.

I took the fact that so many people watched the "dating video" and bought that I was Sam as a nice compliment to my believability as an actor.

I hope that this story will be a good referral and testimonial for me as an actor, as I am still seeking representation.

Having worked frequently with Dennis, I can attest to his gifts as an actor, writer, and genial collaborator.

Dennis and Andrew have teamed up again on The Hayley Project, a soon-to-be-launched online series.

I've "met" Andrew over the phone and e-mail. I'm pretty sure he's real... but is there a real Daniel Murphy? Can we really know for sure?

Comments

O I meta in the park one day,

in the merry merry month of May

may i say this is very confusing? The lesson seems to be that (1) any publicity is good publicity, and (2) never ever assume that two things (on the Net or, now that I think about it, in real life as well) connected only by links will ever stay connected by said link, and may be evaluated by somebody, somewhere as an independent artifact.

And also of course that nothing ever put on the net even once is ever absolutely completely gone. Which gives me hope that those 2002 tapes of Guantanamo torture will pop to the surface eventually.

Which I realize has nothing to do with dating, Esquire magazine, you friend Sam or this writer who saw only the dating video and assumed it was what it purported to be. But Prince Namor says I have gotten so obsessed with everything being political that i have lost any vestige of sense of humor anyway.

I hope, um, everybody had a good time out of the deal. How's that? :)

Looking for a place on your blogroll

I'd appreciate it. Thanks.

Send me mail

I'll add the link.

[x] Any (D) in the general. [ ] Any mullah-sucking billionaire-teabagging torture-loving pus-encrusted spawn of Cthulhu, bless his (R) heart.

"First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win." -- Mahatma Gandhi

Xan, good question...

... what is the moral of the story?

The ones you suggest, IMHO, have merit.

Also -- shocker, I know -- a lot of what's presented in the media stream isn't well-researched or reliably accurate.

But as far as having a good time, it tickled me in two ways:

* Anatomy of a 24-hour "virus" (see the director's blog for more on that)
* As an appearance vs. reality story (always fun, in my book)

What this means is, wingnut

What this means is, wingnut welfare recipient Todd Seavey's personal ad that I linked here in the dating video thread may in fact be the worst personal ad on teh internets.

I win!!111!!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Feed the hamsters...

... that work the wheels that keep the Mighty Corrente servers turning. Help us cover monthly hamster kibble anxiety:

...or provide temporary relief:

Thank you!

I support Americans United for Separation of Church and State.