Day of Shame commemoration -- Gwen Ifill and the MSM: still shameless after all these years
This is the second of my two posts that commemorate the Day of Shame, the sixth anniversary of Colin Powell's UN presentation and the media's chorus of approval for same.
Please share your own recollections and analyses of (what should be) an unforgettably sorry day in American history. If there are other contributions around the Internets, I'll post round-ups here and at dayofshame.com.
Please also read the posts from previous years. Last year, the fifth anniversary, saw many substantial posts around the blogosphere, and the previous year (the first for the Day of Shame blog), this typist hammered out a cluster of posts on the import of the day.
Thanks for your memories!
* * *
Last June, pbs.com offered visitors the opportunity to ask "Five Good Questions" of media fixture Gwen Ifill.
I replied with the following question, under the title "Iraq War reporting":
The media all-but-unanimously pronounced Colin Powell's fact-challenged Feb. 2003 UN presentation "compelling."
As a direct result, the public supported a disastrous and unnecessary war.
What has changed in Beltway reporting as a result of this deadly fiasco?
Powell creedence revival
This is the first of my two posts that commemorate tomorrow's Day of Shame. Please share your own recollections and analyses of — what should be — an unforgettably sorry day in American history!
* * *
The past year has seen much burnishing of the Colin Powell brand:
"Powell is a culturally individuated African American hero" -- Marc Ambinder
"enduring moral authority" -- Editors, The Guardian
"strength and legitimacy" -- Jon Soltz of VoteVets.org
There are those, however, who aren't so willing to vouch for Powell's respectability...
Day of Shame, Sixth Anniversary
dayofshame.com was created to promote observances and analyses of the run-up to the Iraq War and of the fateful day when the reality-based community seemingly lost its charter. And we're looking for you to help recollect, commiserate, and if possible, make sense of it all.
On February 5, 2003, Secretary of State Colin Powell addressed the United Nations to rally support for an invasion of Iraq.
His presentation contained little substance and numerous obvious flaws, and the international community was unimpressed.
America's mainstream media, however, declared it "compelling."
Day of Shame Wrap-Up: We'll Meet Again
Thank you for helping commemorate the fifth anniversary of the biggest sucker deal in Manhattan since Peter Minuit bought the place.
At least the Native Americans got trinkets. All we got from Colin Powell's 2/5/03 U.N. presentation — and the media's unquestioning praise for it — was a costly and unnecessary war.
* * *
Very special thanks go out to Blue Gal at Crooks & Liars, and to those who contributed heartfelt and thoughtful posts to this little memory book.
Because about some things, our memories shouldn't be little, nor should our capacity to question.
See you next year!
Same time, new president. A good one, I hope.
- vastleft's blog
- Login or register to post comments
Day of Shame Links #8
At Maine Owl, The Owl well remembers the day Powell threw us a Curveball and digs into the archives for a chilling timeline of the days of shame that followed the boffo U.N. anthrax-and-pony show. Highly recommended reading.
James at The Mahatma X Files recalls what he said on the first anniversary: "one the most infamous acts of Propaganda in World history. We must never forget."
- vastleft's blog
- Login or register to post comments
Day of Shame Links #7
A Poetic Justice suggests giving peace a chance.
For Alan Perlman, AKA "The Jewish Atheist," the Day of Shame doesn't quite bring on a peaceful, easy feeling. He sees Powell as "a magnificent example of affirmative action run amok."
When asked about his, IMHO, provocative statements about the role of race in Powell's career, Dr. Perlman replied thusly:
Day of Shame Links #6
Elayne Riggs holds out hope that Barack Obama is the anti-Powell.
QSR (Quick Service Restaurant News):
2008-02-04 — The Women's Foodservice Forum (WFF) today announced this year's lineup of keynote speakers for the 2008 WFF Annual Leadership Development Conference, to be held April 13–16 in Washington, D.C. at the new Gaylord National® Resort & Convention Center.
General Colin L. Powell, USA (Ret.), one of the most admired men in America, will deliver a compelling presentation reflecting his years of service at the highest levels of international affairs. He will be speaking on leadership to illustrate precisely what embodies a true leader and demonstrate how to consistently be focused and take responsibility while working to improve processes, organizations and people.
Still doing "compelling presentations" after all these years. No wonder he's so admired!
Day of Shame Links #5
Driftglass marks the Day of Shame with pictures, poetry, and heartfelt prose:
The number of dead Iraqis, who might as well be so many Pac Man dots, so little do they matter to us as real, live human beings anymore. Not that they ever did, really.
- vastleft's blog
- Login or register to post comments
Day of Shame Links #4
On February 7, 2003, Slacktavist described Powell's presentation thusly:
"POWELL'S EVIDENCE LOOKING SHAKY. No smoking gun, lots of smoke and mirrors."
If there's one thing I hate, it's 20/20 hindsight. Goddamn hippies!
See also Editor and Publisher on "5 Years Ago: When the Press Helped Colin Powell Sell the War."
(Both h/t atrios)
- vastleft's blog
- Login or register to post comments
Day of Shame: Live and let die
The internets are chock full of handy lists.
An oft-posted one is "Colin Powell's Rules to Live By," which is generally set up with a gushy intro, like this one:
- vastleft's blog
- Login or register to post comments
Day of Shame Links #2
If you look around YouTube, you'll find that the MSM's Powell/U.N. postmortems are all about rehabilitating the general's reputation.
So, it's left to the blogosphere, and great work like Jonathan Schwarz's, to painstakingly detail the shameful lies.
According to blogger Montag, there was a precedent for Powell's presentation, a long time ago. In a galaxy far, far away.
And if you like things a little more outré, Lambert blurbs MJS's "Bad Magician" series thusly:
Day of Shame Links #1
Here is the first helping of contributions to the Day of Shame blogswarm, 2008...
In reply to this year's call-to-action, whaleshaman muses about that vial of non-anthrax.
Batocchio's superb analysis, like Gaul, is divided into three parts. With understatement that burns, Batocchio says "It wasn't a pleasant feeling, knowing we were almost certainly going to war based on flimsy reasons."
- vastleft's blog
- Login or register to post comments
The day the music died
[Welcome, Crooks & Liars readers!]
dayofshame.com was created to promote observances and analyses of the run-up to the Iraq War and of the fateful day when the reality-based community seemingly lost its charter. And we're looking for you to help recollect, commiserate, and if possible, make sense of it all.
On February 5, 2003, Secretary of State Colin Powell addressed the United Nations to rally support for an invasion of Iraq.
His presentation contained little substance and numerous obvious flaws, and the international community was unimpressed.
America's mainstream media, however, declared it "compelling."



Front page

Recent comments
4 sec ago
6 min 16 sec ago
8 min 22 sec ago
33 min 5 sec ago
35 min 32 sec ago
2 hours 29 min ago
3 hours 17 min ago
3 hours 23 min ago
3 hours 51 min ago
4 hours 21 min ago