The End of the Stem Cell Debate

It's over. The Fundies have once again been conquered by those twin pillars of liberty: science and pr0n.

WOMEN may be able to undergo a "natural" form of breast enlargement using their own stem cells and fat.

The technique, pioneered in Japan, results in breasts that look and feel smoother than conventional cosmetic surgery using implants.

Stem cells, which have the potential to change into any cells in the body, are found in embryos, but the most plentiful supply in adults is from body fat. When body fat is transferred to the breasts, the stem cells enable the fat to grow its own blood supply, thus becoming an integral part of the breast rather than a foreign object.

Dozens of women in Japan have received the enlargements during trials. This month, German authorities gave approval to the process. Under EU rules, this means that the procedure is now legal throughout Europe, including Britain.

But Australian women may have to wait for the procedure to become widely available because of litigation concerns.

Michael Zacharia, president of the Australasian College of Cosmetic Surgery, said the technique could make the detection of subsequent breast cancer more difficult.

While the procedure "gives a very nice natural result", he said it could be hard to determine whether changes occurring in a breast were as a result of cancer or the fat transfer.

"Medical insurance companies just refuse to cover it," he said.

In a separate development, scientists have unearthed a genetic mutation that gives one in four women a small shield against breast cancer.

This is the first concrete discovery of a common gene linked to the disease, and is the biggest breast cancer find since two rare and high-risk genes were identified a decade ago.

Australian researchers contributed to the international study which found a genetic variation that gives some women a 10 per cent reduced risk of breast cancer.

Everyone has the gene, called Caspase 8, but 25 per cent of women of European descent have a mutated variation which gives them a little protection. And 2 per cent have two variations, giving them twice the defence.

Leader of the Australian research arm, Georgia Chenevix-Trench from the Queensland Institute of Medical Research, said confirmation of a low-risk gene for breast cancer was significant.

It has no immediate implications for women already diagnosed with breast cancer, but Dr Chenevix-Trench said researchers expected to unearth similar genes which women could eventually be screened for.

"After that we can start to think about testing protocols to see whether it's worth identifying women who have multiple variants," Dr Chenevix-Trench said.

The results are published in the journal Nature Genetics.

I am laughing to think of the debates this will cause at fundie dinner tables all over Amurka.

Comments

Hmm...

(making scales with hands)

Jesus... tits... Jesus... tits...

I don't think this debate is gonna last very long.

But I still believe
And I will rise up with fists!!

Tanks for Mammaries

May I be a donor? Please?

from Ruth

Man, I'm gonna look like a troll...

...having been ticky-tacky about three CD posts now, even though I love her in that bloggy kind of "I have no idea who you are" sense, but:

Won't this boost the fundie argument that all you need is adult stem cells, not embryonic ones? Or did I miss the point?

matt: think D vs DDD boob size

sure, the adult stem angle is a "problem" here. but this is going to open up that discussion: what could snowflake stem cells do? bring about 20" waists to go with DDD size cups? etc.

fundies are simple, and stupid. they don't hate just "fetus" based stem cell research, they hate all of it, everything that is science. open this door, and all the others open easily. that's why i said, "it's over." b/c once you tie this kind of research to Big Boobs, the rest of it is easy money.

i take your point, but at the same time, i am more hopeful. i see this as a good thing. in the meantime- keep on keepin on. i can take it.

The procedure...

The stem cell breast augmentation was intended for women who had mastectomy. Of course, it can also be used (which, currently used somewhat more frequently) for breast augmentation...
Checkout Cellport Clinic Yokohama for before and after photos. I think, for women who had mastectomy, this could be a better way to get their breast back than putting something alien inside them.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Feed the hamsters...

... that work the wheels that keep the Mighty Corrente servers turning. Help us cover monthly hamster kibble anxiety:

...or provide temporary relief:

Thank you!

I support Americans United for Separation of Church and State.